In praise of imperfection


Hey folks,

​Last week I mentioned a scene that I recently read from the book Underworld by Don DeLillo. Some of you were kind enough to tell me that I botched the link to the scene. Let’s try that again :)


This mistake is apropos of something I’ve been thinking a lot about lately. It seems we’re obsessed with being perfect. Or at least projecting ourselves as perfect. Have you noticed how everyone in the past few years has suddenly been convinced that their writing sucks and that they need to use an LLM to either generate content or proof what they read? I think we’ve bought the lie that we have to be perfect.

Let me clue you in on something that no one seems to know… You don’t need to be perfect. You’re awesome just by the fact that you’re reading this and trying to get better. That’s all that matters. You are enough. You know you want to improve. You are doing something about that. To be perfectly clear, I am not perfect either!

This week while I was doing who knows what on YouTube, I came across this video about piano YouTube. The gist was that most people teaching others how to play the piano online are lying. They use a visualizer that shows the keys being hit as the music plays and as the instructor is playing the piano (think Guitar Hero but Piano Hero). The audience of these videos, people trying to learn to play the piano, is led to believe that the person playing the piano is hitting the notes indicated on the visualizer and producing the music we hear. Only they aren’t. When the video is slowed down and the analyst zoom in, we see the “teacher” is mishitting notes. Others are playing very slowly and then speed up the playback to make them look amazing fast. All this to make people who I suspect are pretty good pianists look perfect to their audience of students.

I probably got to this video because I’m a sucker for a channel called Wings of Pegasus where the host, Fil, watches “live” music performances hosted on YouTube and then analyzes them to detect whether pitch correction (e.g., autotune) has been used and whether the singer is lip-synching. Nearly everyone is using pitch correction: live and in the studio. TV talent shows are a scam. The sad thing is that many of these performers have amazing natural voices. They don’t need pitch correction. In many cases it’s hard to hear the difference. But people do it anyway because they want to be Judy Garland. Only Judy Garland wasn’t perfect. She certainly didn’t use pitch correction! But, we know she - rather than a computer algorithm - was amazing because we knew what she actually sounded like. We have lost this ability with modern music.

These videos remind me of other imperfect icons. Does anyone think Bob Dylan has a good voice? Are XKCD comics as beautiful as the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel? Of course not. But they don’t need to be. The rough edges are part of their charm and their story. Dylan and XKCD communicate important ideas through their craft. It’s the message that’s important to them, not the auditory or visual artistry. It’s as if criticizing their imperfections shows how much you don’t get it.

If you’ve ever watched my videos you know that my programming is not perfect. I have so many typos. I have stray thoughts that send me down dark alleys. I forget syntax. On and on. You get the unvarnished Pat coding away on my livestreams. Generally, I have proven to myself that I can generate the figure a couple of days before the livestream. But that’s about all the practice I have before going live. If someone makes a suggestion to do something different and I run with it, what follows is completely unpracticed. My recorded videos are a bit different. I do edit those. Also, I don’t really “practice” these beforehand. Most of the editing is to remove dead air while I wait for code to run or for me to gather my thoughts or me going to scold my kids for beating on each other. Some amount of the mistakes also get edited out. If you’ve seen the recorded and live videos you can kind of see the difference. Regardless of the editing, these videos are very much not perfect.

This type of teaching is generally called “live coding”. This is how I’ve been teaching R for at least 10 years. I’m not sure where I initially learned to teach this way, but I’m pretty sure I was strongly influenced by people like Greg Wilson and others in the Software Carpentry orbit. Why teach this way? Why not be more professional and clean up the videos to remove the mistakes? That would be a lie. That would be me projecting something that I am not and something that you cannot be. Although the mistakes are 100% honest, I intentionally leave them in to show how someone that uses these tools and knows them pretty well makes mistakes. It regularizes failure.

Aside from authenticity, why do I do this? Over the years I have learned that a big part of programming is being able to resolve bugs or things going sideways. If I give you perfect code and never show you any error messages, then I can’t teach you how to debug your code. At least once a livestream, I get an error or an unexpected result and my immediate reaction is something like, “Oh sh**, I did something wrong and this livestream is doomed”. By talking through the problem and trying to explain my thought process I can resolve the bug and return on my way. Hopefully, it also provides an example of how to solve your own problems.

If I were going for views, watch time, and subscribers (i.e., $) I would record and edit my videos. According to YouTube, the channel was its healthiest when I was only posting recorded content. To be honest, my numbers have stalled since I started livestreaming. That’s fine. Aside from not needing to spend hours editing, the value of livestreaming content is having someone from the other side of the world ask a question or make a suggestion. Obviously, I can’t do that in a recorded video. But answering that question or trying a suggestion is how we all learn. My perfect lesson plan only gets me so far. At some point someone in the audience helps me improve it.

I don’t watch any other channels that put up programming content. Frankly, my understanding is that the popularity of educational content has cratered on YouTube because of AI. Regardless, my sense is that there aren’t many people doing what I do. Some people post pretty scripted videos telling you how to use a specific function or do a routine task. Those functions always work perfectly in isolation with well tested datasets. More power to those creators. I find that boring. I prefer the chaos of trying to blend 20 functions to make something really cool from someone’s disaster of an Excel file.

What do I want you to take away from this? You don’t need to be perfect. You are good enough. You want to grow. That’s enough. The benefit to you for realizing this is that you get to take the unexpected detours, you have the pride in making something that reflects your humanity, and you become more comfortable in your own body. I think that if we could all figure out those things, then the world would be a much better place.

Workshops

I'm pleased to be able to offer you one of three recent workshops! With each you'll get access to 18 hours of video content, my code, and other materials. Click the buttons below to learn more

In case you missed it…

Here is a livestream that I published this week that relate to previous content from these newsletters. Enjoy!

​
video preview​video preview​

Finally, if you would like to support the Riffomonas project financially, please consider becoming a patron through Patreon! There are multiple tiers and fun gifts for each. By no means do I expect people to become patrons, but if you need to be asked, there you go :)

I’ll talk to you more next week!

Pat

​

Riffomonas Professional Development

Read more from Riffomonas Professional Development

Hey folks, As I mentioned last week, I’m considering jumping platforms to use Substack to disseminate these newsletters and try to build more interactivity between you all and me. Because of how different email providers process emails, it’s become very difficult to have any confidence in how many people read these emails and who all is interacting with the content. Since I pay by the subscriber I’m likely paying for subscribers who may never open the emails (although their email provider...

Hey folks, Can you let me know if you use substack to read and comment on newsletters? I’m thinking about changing platforms for this newsletter and would love to get your opinion on what the experience on substack is like for you as an audience member versus through an email newsletter like this one. Something amazing happened on Wednesday morning. At some point earlier in the week, I updated the software I use to do my Wednesday’s streams, which is called OBS. Upon launching OBS I got a...

Hey folks, It’s great to be back sending out this newsletter and posting videos! I hope you had a chance to check out the critique and livestream that I posted earlier this week. To be honest, I almost didn’t cover these figures because I truly strive to be constructive in this newsletter and in my content. Please feel free to email me if you think I should pull together a more formal description of the issues in the original paper to send to the authors before sending out to Nature...