Hey folks, Next week is Thanksgiving here in the US and I’ll skip sending you another newsletter. In exchange, you’ll get three videos on YouTube inspired by a newsletter post from October talking about a descending bar plot with a pattern in one of the bars. Before you thank me, you might want to check out today’s newsletter🤣! I’ve always enjoyed the old 538’s articles and appreciated the data centric point of view of its founder Nate Silver. He has a Substack newsletter, “Silver Bulletin”, that is very good. I’m too cheap to pay for a subscription, so I settle for the bread crumbs he includes on the free subscription. Last night I received his latest article, Hopium comes at a high price. The article is part of a debrief on the election and the state of polling and predictive models like his. His contention is that polls continues to underestimate Trump’s numbers, but within the margin of error of those polls. Regardless of what you think of Trump or Silver’s analysis, I was captivated by the visual that he included in the newsletter. As always, I encourage you to ask some questions about any plot you find to help you develop your taste and and think through how you would recreate elements of a plot. What type of plot is this? Aside from the data story, what is interesting about this figure? What do you like about it? What don’t you like about it? Can you outline the steps you would take to generate the figure? What are some of the steps you aren’t sure about and would like to learn? This plot was eerily reminiscent of a plot that I made back in 2021 showing the likelihood of people getting the COVID-19 vaccine at different times by country. I called this plot a “dumbbell” or “barbell” plot because for each entity (e.g., state or country) there is a ball connected by a line - it looks like a dumbbell. You might recall another set of videos I made recently based on paired data where I made a scatter plot and a slope plot inspired by sentiments of farmers and non-farmers in Sweden. A dumbbell plot is another way to show paired data for a handful of entities. If I were asked to recreate Silver’s figure, I’d expect to get a data frame with three columns -
At a basic level, a dumbbell plot can be made with with a combination of Let’s start with the handles. Using my What about the “bells”? For those, I need all of the polling data in a single column. I’d need to generate a second data frame using The labels are a bit more tricky. I’d use I was also struck by the “legend” across the top indicating the white point is the polling average margin and the green the actual margin. I’d probably use a few The axis labels also have some cool things going on. The x-axis text is a pretty slick way of embedding who was favored to the left and right of the black line at zero. I’d use Finally, the plot has vertical grid lines that are grey. There’s also one that is black at zero. We could do one or the other in the This figure shows the 7 “battleground” states from the election. Because of how our elections work, it’s the state one wins that matters, not the number of votes they get overall. So, although Harris won California by 21%, she still got the same number of electoral votes as if she had only one it by 1%. Ditto for Trump and Texas. Regardless, it would be interesting to see these types of data for the 43 other states. Beyond being more complete, I’m interested in this to whether the same ~2.5 percentage point difference holds up regardless of the state. Maybe I’ll see if I can track that data down between now and when I produce the remake video, likely in January. I’ll award bonus points if anyone does that for me :)
|
Hey folks! I’m in proposal writing mode again. Unfortunately, I am finding my weekly search for a data visualization to share with you is leading me down unproductive internet rabbit holes. So, I thought I’d share an idea with you that I hope resonates. If you have any reactions, please send them my way! For the past year or so I have been recreating other people’s data visualizations in an attempt to learn new techniques with R and expand the type of data that I normally visualize. The idea...
Hey folks! Here in the US, vaccines continue to be a hot button issue. I feel like this issue is really an amalgamation of multiple issues including the decline in respect for authority figures, frustration with COVID, inability to assess risk at a personal level, and parents feeling like they are losing rights. Do people really want their kids to get sick unnecessarily? I doubt it. It’s also in the news because the Secretary of Health and Human Services is a vaccine skeptic/denier with many...
Hey folks! Sorry for the hiatus in getting you a newsletter into your inbox. The end of the summer/beginning of the academic year has been pretty chaotic. Actually, I had what I thought would be an interesting plot to recreate, but then I wasn’t able to find the original data and I wasn’t really interested in simulating it. Oh well. I’m also finding it hard to come up with interesting data visualizations from out in the wild. One of my go-to’s, Philip Bump, stopped working for the Washington...